competition, sessile, invasive, oyster, Crassostrea virginica, Balanus spp.
Populations of Crassostrea virginica within Mosquito Lagoon, Florida have recently undergone significant die-offs, which are a subject of major concern. Restoration efforts within Mosquito Lagoon are focusing on reconstructing the three-dimensional reef habitats. Before effective protocols can be established, however, important questions about the sources of juvenile and adult oyster mortality must be answered. Potential causes of Crassostrea virginica mortality in the Indian River Lagoon system include sediment loads, competition, predation, and disease. My research focused on the interactions between oysters and the competitors that may affect the settlement, growth, and survival of Crassostrea virginica. The four objectives of my thesis research were to: 1) identify potential oyster competitors in Mosquito Lagoon, 2) determine if the sessile species recruiting to oyster shells have changed over time, 3) determine how the dominant competitors, barnacles, affect oyster settlement, growth and survival, and 4) determine if oyster or barnacle larvae are better able to settle in increased sediment and flow conditions that are associated with high levels of recreational boating. Lift nets were deployed within Mosquito Lagoon to determine available competing species. I collected species inventory data at six sites to determine the sessile invertebrate species (competitors) present on oyster reefs. Nets were deployed intertidally, just above mean low water, on living oyster reefs. One and a half liters of live and dead oysters were placed within the nets upon deployment. The nets were picked up monthly and surveyed for all fauna. Upon retrieval, all oysters within each net were brought back to the lab where all sessile organisms were immediately identified and returned to the lagoon. This survey began June 2004 and continued for one year. Shells from historic shell middens (up to 15,000 years old) were examined to determine if the sessile species settling on oyster reefs have changed over time. Similar species were found on both shells of historic and extant reefs. One notable exception was the appearance of Balanus amphitrite, an invasive barnacle, on the extant reefs. Balanus amphitrite is thought to have invaded Mosquito Lagoon approximately 100 years ago. This has resulted in a five fold increase in barnacle abundance per oyster shell. Balanus spp. were identified as important potential competitors and thus my research focused on spatial competition between C. virginica and native versus invasive barnacles of the area. Over 300 barnacles, including a native species, Balanus eburneus, and an invasive, Balanus amphitrite, have been counted on a single oyster shell. To determine how Balanus spp. affected settlement, growth, and survivorship of C. virginica, laboratory and field experiments were conducted in which densities of Balanus amphitrite and Balanus eburneus were manipulated. Density treatments included: no barnacles (control), low, medium, and high coverage of barnacles. Laboratory settlement trials with cultured oyster larvae were run in still water and flow (recirculating flume) using all barnacle density treatments. Additionally, all treatments with 7-day oyster spat were deployed in the field to follow oyster spat growth and survivorship. Settlement was counted by microscopy, and growth and survivorship were measured every 3 days for 4 weeks. Settlement of oysters was affected by barnacle presence only in flowing water. Still water trials showed no oyster preference related to any barnacle density or species. The presence of barnacles affected the growth and survivorship of oyster spat. However, there were no species specific differences. Studies suggest that recreational boating activities, especially boat wakes that cause sediment resuspension, may decrease recruitment and this may then provide an advantage to sessile competitors less affected by flow and sediment loads. To address these issues, replicated laboratory trials were run in a laboratory flume to quantify the effects of water motion (0, 5, 10 cm/s) and sediment loads (0, 8, 16 g/ml) on oyster recruitment and the recruitment of an important, relatively new competitor in the system, the barnacle Balanus amphitrite. If B. amphitrite settles in a wider variety of flow rates and sediment conditions, it may have a competitive advantage over the native oyster in this space-limited habitat. I found that high flow and sediment loads reduced larval settlement of C. virginica. Alternatively, settlement of cyprids of B. amphitrite did not differ among treatments. Thus, continuous boat traffic during settlement times should favor recruitment of the invasive barnacle Balanus amphitrite over the native oyster Crassostrea virginica. Determination of the competitive interactions of Crassostrea virginica in Mosquito Lagoon gives us important insights into the ecological conditions necessary for reestablishment of these oyster populations. Crassostrea virginica in Mosquito Lagoon was significantly impacted by barnacles; settlement, growth, and survivorship were all reduced by Balanus spp. This information will help resource managers in planning restoration techniques to minimize oyster and barnacle competitive interactions and increase Crassostrea virgininca success.
Walters, Linda J.
Master of Science (M.S.)
College of Arts and Sciences
Length of Campus-only Access
Masters Thesis (Open Access)
Boudreaux, Michelle, "Native And Invasive Competitors Of The Eastern Oyster Crassostrea Virginica In Mosquito Lagoon, Florida" (2005). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 532.