Keywords
library, censorship, academic libraries, LGBTQ
Abstract
This chapter explores the rarely discussed but impactful issue of internal censorship within academic libraries, focusing on challenges to LGBTQ+ materials. Drawing on personal experiences at a regional public university in the American South, the author recounts multiple instances where library staff and leadership acted in ways that undermined the inclusion of LGBTQ+ resources. These incidents ranged from quietly removing or hiding books to resisting the addition of LGBTQ+ periodicals and graphic novels, and even denying purchase requests without explanation. The chapter underscores how fear of controversy, personal bias, and institutional conservatism can result in "soft censorship," despite the profession's commitment to intellectual freedom.
Phillips contextualizes these events in a broader framework, highlighting the importance of proactive collection development policies, faculty outreach, and open internal communication. By emphasizing the library’s role in representing marginalized communities—especially in geographically and culturally isolated areas—the chapter advocates for vigilance, allyship, and strategic advocacy to protect diverse collections. Ultimately, the piece serves as both a cautionary tale and a guide for librarians seeking to uphold the principles of inclusion and access in their institutions.
Publication Date
2-2025
Original Citation
Phillips, J. D. (2025). Enemies Within the Gates: Contending with Internal Censorship Challenges. In Phillips, J. D. and Ruud, J. (Eds.), Censorship Is a Drag: LGBTQ Materials and Programming Under Siege in Libraries, (pp. 109-122). Series on Gender and Sexuality in Librarianship, no. 16. Sacramento: Library Juice Press.
Document Type
Book Chapter
Copyright Status
Publisher retained
Publication Version
Pre-print
Location
Orlando (Main) Campus
Department
UCF Libraries
STARS Citation
Phillips, Jason D., "Enemies Within the Gates: Contending with Internal Censorship Challenges" (2025). Faculty Scholarship and Creative Works. 1326.
https://stars.library.ucf.edu/ucfscholar/1326