Title

Experimental methods and elicitation of values

Authors

Authors

G. W. Harrison; R. M. Harstad;E. E. Rutstrom

Comments

Authors: contact us about adding a copy of your work at STARS@ucf.edu

Abbreviated Journal Title

Exp. Econ.

Keywords

experiments; valuation; auctions; incentive-compatibility; LABORATORY EXPERIMENTAL AUCTIONS; HYPOTHETICAL SURVEYS; MARKETING-RESEARCH; Economics

Abstract

Experimental methods are currently being extensively used to elicit subjective values for commodifies and projects. Three methodological problems are not systematically addressed in this emerging literature. The first is the potential for laboratory responses to be censored by field opportunities, so that lab responses can be confounded by uncontrolled knowledge of the field; the second is the potential for subjective perceptions about field opportunities, and hence valuation responses, to be affected by the institution used to elicit values; and the third is the potential for some elicitation institutions to influence subjective perceptions of characteristics of the commodity or project being valued, and hence change the very commodity being valued. All three problems result in potential loss of control over the value elicitation process. For example, we show that censoring affects conclusions drawn in a major study of beef packaging valuation. We derive implications for experimental designs that minimize the potential effect of these methodological problems.

Journal Title

Experimental Economics

Volume

7

Issue/Number

2

Publication Date

1-1-2004

Document Type

Article

Language

English

First Page

123

Last Page

140

WOS Identifier

WOS:000225201800001

ISSN

1386-4157

Share

COinS