Auditors' Consideration of Material Income-Increasing versus Material Income-Decreasing Items during the Audit Process

    Authors

    N. K. Desai;G. J. Gerard

    Comments

    Authors: contact us about adding a copy of your work at STARS@ucf.edu

    Abbreviated Journal Title

    Audit.-J. Pract. Theory

    Keywords

    memory; accruals, auditing; risk; conservatism; EARNINGS MANAGEMENT; RECOGNITION MEMORY; DECISION-MAKING; NUMERICAL; DATA; BONUS PLANS; RETRIEVAL; KNOWLEDGE; RISK; ASSESSMENTS; LITIGATION; Business, Finance

    Abstract

    We examine how auditors' consideration of material items is affected by each item's directional impact on income. Prior research indicates that auditors face greater litigation risk for non-detection of fraudulent income-increasing items compared to income-decreasing items. Therefore, we expect that auditors will spend greater cognitive effort evaluating material income-increasing (as opposed to income-decreasing) items, resulting in superior memories for such items. However, in an effort to direct auditors' attention to both increasing and decreasing material items, we manipulate whether or not auditors were asked to form expectations about the future effects of material items. Our results indicate that auditors' memories for income-increasing items are significantly greater than that for income-decreasing items when auditors are not asked to form expectations about the future effects of the items. However, this difference is not observed when auditors are asked to form expectations about future effects of each item. Furthermore, our results indicate that auditors are less likely to refer back to the work papers to verify the accuracy of income-decreasing items compared to income-increasing items. This suggests that auditors are not inclined to compensate for their poor memory of income-decreasing items by referring to working papers. However, it also suggests that auditors compensate for the greater risk associated with income-increasing items by requiring greater verification of such items.

    Journal Title

    Auditing-a Journal of Practice & Theory

    Volume

    32

    Issue/Number

    2

    Publication Date

    1-1-2013

    Document Type

    Article

    Language

    English

    First Page

    33

    Last Page

    51

    WOS Identifier

    WOS:000317837300002

    ISSN

    0278-0380

    Share

    COinS