High Impact Practices Student Showcase Fall 2026

An Analysis of Individual VS. Group Work in Undergraduate Chemistry Laboratories

An Analysis of Individual VS. Group Work in Undergraduate Chemistry Laboratories

Streaming Media

Files

Course Code

CHM

Course Number

4942

Faculty/Instructor

Dr. Matthew Rex

Faculty/Instructor Email

[email protected]

About the Author

We are both Undergraduate Research Assistants for undergraduate chemistry laboratories. During discussion in Dr. Rex's class, we discovered that despite having the same instructional roles, our laboratory environment contrasted each other. Christina assisted in the Chemistry Fundamental labs where students were encouraged to work in groups. Ashley assisted in the Analytical Chemistry labs where students worked individually. This prompted us to analyze benefits and drawbacks of the different work environments between each of our labs. We would like to thank Dr. Rex for fostering open class discussions that we used in this project. We would also like to Dr. Saitta and Dr. Froelich for allowing us to assist in their labs. 

Abstract, Summary, or Creative Statement

This project explores how collaborative and independent learning environments in undergraduate chemistry laboratories contribute to student development and career readiness. To conduct this analysis, we examined and compared the specific educational benefits and drawbacks of both group work and individual lab work in two different UCF chemistry labs. We then evaluated how each learning style impacts overall readiness for future careers in STEM fields. Through this comparison, we learned that neither approach fully prepares students on its own, as each cultivates distinct yet essential professional skills. Collaborative learning strengths communication, peer instruction, and shared problem-solving, through it carries risk like unequal participation and student dependency. Conversely, independent learning builds technical skills, self-sufficiency, and individual accountability, but it limits social interaction and teamwork opportunities. Ultimately, our main takeaway is that STEM careers require a balance of teamwork and personal responsibility. Exposing students to both collaborative and independent lab environments helps them become more adaptable, confident decision-makers who are better equipped for their future careers.

Keywords

ULA, Undergraduate Learning Assistant, Laboratories, Chemistry, Group Work, Individual Work

An Analysis of Individual VS. Group Work in Undergraduate Chemistry Laboratories


Share

COinS
 

Accessibility Statement

This item was created or digitized prior to April 24, 2027, or is a reproduction of legacy media created before that date. It is preserved in its original, unmodified state specifically for research, reference, or historical recordkeeping. In accordance with the ADA Title II Final Rule, the University Libraries provides accessible versions of archival materials upon request. To request an accommodation for this item, please submit an accessibility request form.